Civic Spaces in Times of Climate Crisis - MHI




Civic Spaces in
Times of Climate Crisis

Why Psychology Needs to 
Rethink what it Means to 
Heal in A Dwindling World

Dr. Garret Barnwell


Athulya Pillai


illustrator’s bio

Amreeta Banerjee

Alice A. Barwa completed her MA in Education from Dr. B.R. Ambedkar Univerity, Delhi (AUD), in 2022, and is from the Oraon Adivasi community, a native of Chhotanagpur Plateau, Chhattisgarh. She has been an advocate for Adivasi rights and voices as a member of an Adivasi youth collective @TheAdivasiPost, and has been an Adivasi youth representative at UN Climate Change Conference in Glasgow, Scotland, in 2021. Her research interests include education, culture, sociology, and linguistics.

The world is at a dangerous crossroad. Our dependence on extractive resources is pushing the earth to a new, hotter, and more barren reality. If psychology truly wants to be fit for purpose in this new reality, it must defend civic spaces.

Climate change is more severe and widespread than previously expected. Most of the world’s ecosystems upon which life depends have been irreparably harmed.

Disasters, such as mass species die-offs, droughts, and famines are occurring at unprecedented levels. This destruction is inseparable from a demand for resources that is so unsustainable that the Earth cannot keep pace, lacking the ability to replenish itself annually1. In fact, it would take almost two Earths at this time to do so. Climate-related devastation is expected to dramatically worsen over the next two decades2

Much of this destruction is part of a larger arch of colonial capitalism — or the varying but globally-networked systems of labour, financial flows, and conceptions of property that constituted colonial economies. 

Within these structures, imperial powers saw colonies as sources of raw materials or “resources” for distant metropoles. Thus, extractivism or the “particular way of thinking and the properties and practices organised toward the goal of maximizing benefit through (resource) extraction” — was a key facet of colonial capitalism. 

Today, although most colonial administrations have been dismantled, systems of extractivism remain pervasive — whether enacted through states or the corporations they support. Life within this logic, as Vandana Shiva explains, is treated like an open-access system, where local ways of being in the world, such as a sense of community as well as sovereignty and public participation, are not only undermined but seen as threats to extractivism. As a consequence, civic space is critically under threat. 

Psychology has played a perverse role in this process. In using terms like ‘climate anxiety’ to describe climate-related distress, mainstream psychology risks pathologising and individualising distress resulting from the violence of capitalism. Historically, in placing the responsibility for distress on the individual’s internal psychic reality — or at most, on the family — psychology conceals how capitalism operates, and societal suffering. 

Yet, suffering does not circulate through our lives and relationships as some passive response to anxieties about these crises. Rather, these anxieties arise as part of our experience of alienation, marginalisation, and exclusion in society that stems from ways of privileging capitalism — including extractivism — that destroys ways of life and societal bonds. 

As under colonialism, extractivism’s proponents today still largely make the rules: they help develop weak environmental regulatory frameworks, for instance. At other times, they spearhead deals for extractive projects in the name of “development” and “progress,” but that often neglects rights to participation and self-determination for affected communities.

Today, capitalism is reproducing the same colonialist, racist logic that deemed much of the world’s population living on the margins expendable. This is particularly true at points of extraction, where United Nations Special Rapporteur, David Boyd says communities are transformed into “sacrifice zones” where environmental degradation, pollution, and unjust social arrangements pose extreme threats to well-being. 

A critical dimension to these unjust social arrangements that create suffering is the status of civic space. Civic space is defined as the ability to organise, communicate, and participate meaningfully without hindrance or the threat of harm. 

The closing down of civic space allows extractivism to create conditions in which residents who might organise, communicate, and seek meaningful participation to oppose extractivism are deemed a threat. Being labelled as a threat, in turn, sanctions silencing, exclusion, and physical violence toward community and environmental defenders. 

This contributes to the wanton approval of deleterious mining and logging projects, the murders of land and environmental defenders, and other human rights violations. 

Thus, these subjugating acts that close down civic space may, in turn, create significant anguish among those who resist – not by choice, but because of their very locality. 

For many around the world, it is not climate change as some abstract weather occurrence that is distressing, but rather the grating against colonial capitalism in one’s daily life. Our pain indicates to us that there is something wrong with the colonial world order that seeks to repress differences in being and worldviews. 

We need to resist the erosion of civic space and actively accompany one another, share experiences, and shoulder the risks. 
Those who are effectively resisting often do so for the well-being of their community and find strength, hope, and meaning in these solidarities. 

As mental health workers, we must be more active in documenting the psycho-political threats to civic space and in strategising together ways of resisting them and of promoting other ways of being in the world. Instead of perpetuating extractive dynamics, our practices must be connected to community struggles and feed into processes that contest power. 

Gone is the luxury of being a neutral observer. 

In our re-orientation, we can also learn from indigenous psychologies, radical psychoanalysis, and other critical psychologies to find new languages and ideas to name and contest colonial capitalism’s tactics, including the misuse and abuse of our intimate lives. Most importantly, we should be led by those resisting and asserting other ways of becoming in the world. 

Cite this Article View all References


  • This Year, Earth Overshoot Day Fell on July 28. Earth Overshoot Day. Global Footprint Network.
  • Climate Change 2022: Impacts, Adaptation and Vulnerability. 
  • Utah Phillips (1935 –2008), who identified as an anarchist, was an American labor organizer, folk singer, storyteller and poet from America. He often promoted the Industrial Workers of the World in his music, actions, and words. Retrieved from Accessed 22 September, 2022. 
  • Fridays for Future is an international climate movement active in most countries. It is a youth-led and -organised global climate strike movement that started in August 2018. Retrieved from on August 31, 2022. 
  • Buechner, M. 1 billion children at ‘extremely high’ risk from climate change. UNICEF USA, 2021.  Retrieved from on August 31, 2022. 
  • Burton, Nylah. People Of Color Experience Climate Grief More Deeply Than White People. Vice.Com, 2020, Retrieved from
  • Climate Psychology Alliance. Retrieved from on August 31, 2022,
  • Dhar, S. Millions displaced by cyclone in India and Bangladesh. Reuters, 2009.  Retrieved from on August 31, 2022. 
  • Hersher, R.. The Arctic suicides: It’s not the dark that kills you. NPR, 2016.  Retrieved August 31, 2022, from 
  • Hickman, C., Marks, E., Pihkala, P., Clayton, S., Lewandowski, R. E., Mayall, E. E., Wray, B., Mellor, C., & van Susteren, L.. “Climate anxiety in children and young people and their beliefs about government responses to climate change: A global survey”. The Lancet Planetary Health, 5(12). 2021. Retrieved from 
  • Mogul, R., Mitra, E., Suri, M., & Saifi, S.. “India and Pakistan Heatwave is ‘testing the limits of human survivability,’ expert says”. CNN. 2022. Retrieved from on August 31, 2022. 
  • Ray, S. J. . Climate anxiety is an overwhelmingly white phenomenon, Scientific American. 2021. Retrieved from on August 31, 2022.



R : Locating Adivasi Self within Environmental Jus...